Monday, 16 November 2026

False Evidence by James Chandler

“False Evidence” by James Chandler is the third instalment in the Sam Johnstone series.


Sam Johnstone, ex-veteran and defense attorney struggles to cope with his PTSD, spiralling further into addiction following a fallout with his business partner and a breakup with his girlfriend. Despite repeated attempts to get his life back on track, he keeps relapsing, finding himself trapped in a vicious cycle.


With his personal life in disarray, he takes up an assault case when Lucy Beretta, the wife of a local university president, walks into his office, visibly bruised. 


She claims to have been followed and assaulted by Tanner Richards, an acquaintance she met at a bar. Sam takes up her case, but to his surprise Tanner eventually admits to the assault and accepts a prison sentence.


However, things take an unexpected turn after Tanner’s release from prison. Lucy is arrested for his alleged murder at her residence, which she claims was an act of self-defence.




Sam is compelled to take up the murder trial, representing Lucy in her defence. With the “stand-your-ground” law seemingly working in her favour, Sam expects it to be an open-and-shut case. However, things get complicated when he discovers that Lucy hasn’t been entirely truthful.


The novel, built around this interesting premise, has all the potential to become an edge-of-the-seat courtroom drama. However, it takes far too long to settle into the narrative. The legal proceedings are explained at considerable length, sometimes to the point of feeling like an overkill.


There are also inconsistencies in the narration, with certain plotlines left open and never brought to a proper conclusion. Whether these are genuine loose ends or deliberate leads to the next instalment remains unclear.




It is only when the actual courtroom drama begins that the novel picks up pace. While the proceedings in the court are written with attention to detail, the narrative once again gets bogged down by an overdose of procedural explanations.


The novel does manage to deliver some gripping moments, with certain courtroom sequences brilliantly written. However, Sam Johnstone’s brilliance as a character falls short of what we have come to expect from the previous instalments in the series.


Despite its shortcomings, “False Evidence” is a decent courtroom drama from James Chandler.


No comments:

Post a Comment

False Evidence by James Chandler

“False Evidence” by James Chandler is the third instalment in the Sam Johnstone series. Sam Johnstone, ex-veteran and defense attorney str...